Jason wrote:
> > But honestly, my hon-baren is better... much better!
>Anyone care to quantify, for a pre-beginner, how one little flat disk that
>you rub on the back of a piece of paper could be say, 100 times better
>than another. (I'm comparing "starting at $640" to $8 here:
>
http://www.imcclains.com/catalog/baren/ ). When I first saw that I chalked
>it up to the same kind of Japanese materials fetishism that results in
>things like multi-thousand-dollar Go boards, but I figure there must be
>something to it or you'all wouldn't be buying them.
My hon-baren is an 8-strand 'medium' and was made by Gosho-san and
purchased from the Baren Mall here:
http://www.barenforum.org/mall/products/hon_baren.php lead-time for
delivery of Gosho-san's barens became incredibly long and unpredictable, so
Baren now offers the equivalent Kikuhide-san baren which ship much faster
-- only three to six months and only $750 to $1,000 !!! It is such a
reliable and sensitive tool compared to any other I've used -- alive in my
hand and wonderful to use...
David Bull was right-on when he wrote, "They are absolutely beautiful tools
... not for everybody, but if you have built up a fair amount of experience
in woodblock printmaking, then once you have a chance to try one of these
tools, you will never be willing to go back to a cheaper option!"
The Murasaki baren is the next-best, and although it is only 1/2 or 2/3 as
great as my hon-baren, it's only 1/10th the price... The Murasaki medium
13cm is an excellent tool, beautifully made (by the same Kikuhide as the
hon-barens and available from both McClains and Baren Mall -- I recommend
this one as the tool to get if you're on a budget -- it feels much 'harder'
and less sensitive than the hon-baren, but prints very well, nonetheless:
$116.50 Murasaki 13cm Medium baren from Baren Mall:
http://www.barenforum.org/mall/products/barens.php (McClains only carry
the 12cm model which, in my opinion, is a bit too small a tool. Baren
Mall's price for the 12cm medium is $92.23 compared to McClains at $130).
If you're really on a tight budget, the $36.89 Sosaku Baren (Sumi-fine or
Beta-medium) 12 or 13cm
http://www.barenforum.org/mall/products/barens.php
is a decent tool -- if you can only get one, you'll probably be happier
with the "beta" model after a break-in period.
The designations, "fine", "medium", and "strong" are related to the surface
area which actually contacts the block -- the working surface of a baren is
not smooth (like a wooden spoon or something) but bumpy -- the more bumps
which contact the block (and the 'softer' or flatter they are) the 'finer'
the baren, and the fewer bumps which contact the block (and the 'harder' or
pointier they are) the 'stronger' the baren. 'fine' baren are better for
printing delicate lines and details where not much surface area of the
block is printing and 'strong' baren are better for printing big flat areas
where the block is all printing and not carved -- 'coarse' or 'strong'
baren have more of a tendency to leave baren-suji (darker marks left by
those 'bumps'), and 'fine' baren won't print large flat areas of color very
well no matter how hard you try to press...
One caution: All baren when they are new seem to have some of the 'bumps'
which stick out more than others, so new baren leave pronounced marks in
the print which record the movement of the baren for posterity... The more
you use the baren (and maybe try to smash the largest of these (using your
finger nail or something) each time you re-cover the tool), the less
pronounced these become until the tool is well 'broken in' after several
thousand impressions.
-- Mike
Mike Lyon
http://mlyon.com